Don’t you just hate it when someone says something and for
the next five minutes, repeats him or herself with the same point, just in a
multitude of ways? I know I do and that’s why I will spare you the ‘movie
review’ of a movie all of us are watching together. Because in all
truthfulness, it’s my opinion, there’s not much more to add to the observations
about the movie itself that our classmates are blogging about and, perhaps it’s
the over-stressed mood I’m in right now, but I just don’t think I’ll offer any
further ‘insight’ without sounding patronizing. However, that’s said, I will
contribute my thoughts about the movie thus far and in doing so, perhaps
‘brainstorm’ some of the qualities I would like to compare in my up-coming
Thesis driven paper.
When following up on the first half of the movie with a
little research on my own, I came across a review that eloquently summarized
the plot and I don’t think I can write it out any clearer then Murray Chapman
did when he wrote, “Jaime Escalante is a mathematics teacher in a school in a
Hispanic neighborhood. Convinced that his students have potential, he adopts
unconventional teaching methods, help gang members and no-hopers pass the
rigorous Advanced Placement exam in calculus.”
Through the use of creative solutions to varied challenges that
arose for the students in his classes, Escalante build a level of trust with
the students and in return, the students felt ‘safe’ enough to let their
defenses (physical, emotional and mental) down. The end result was the student’s
willingness to rise to the challenges set before them.
*** I responded to a fellow students blog regarding the 'contract' Mr. Escalante had his students sign. I read her post after I had written my own and I realized as I was responding to her with something I truly felt about the beginning part of the movie so I wanted to add it to my own post. ***
"... You have made an interesting point when you brought up the ‘contract’
that Mr. Escalante drew up for his math students to sign. I think that putting his
words, expectations and consequences down in written form, he left little room
for 'excuses’ and a lot of room for ‘potential.’
He knew and understood that these young adults all had one
thing in common and that was: they all felt like their ‘power’ was always being
taken from them. Someone was always dictating the outcome of their lives and by
offering them something they could control, he was offering the world, but it
had to be the students choice otherwise, he knew what he offered to them was
little more then lip-service. By signing the form, they took responsibility for
their: classwork, education, extra-curriculum activities, input into their educational
experience and in the end, their futures.
He empowered his students to make a choice and then to
follow through with that decision, regardless of what challenges may arise. He
outlined and detailed what his expectations were and then left it in the hands
of those who he had enough faith in to make a decision they would benefit from
for the rest of their lives."
I really like how clear you are about what you are writing about; I think it adds insight. I look at your writing style and see ways I can improve my own without droning on about the plot. I like your point about power and the role it plays in this film, because I too think its an important one. I think that power is the reason the students responded as they did.
ReplyDeleteI really liked your post and that quote that you found. I remember that comment and I never looked at it like that. You brought up a wonderful point to light and I thank you for that.
ReplyDeleteWow, Christa--way to blog! I love that you went beyond the movie and looked into the historical truth here, a great addition to our discussions. Please be sure to bring this up in class on Tuesday, either before or after we begin watching Dead Poets Society, as it will be instructive in comparing idealized teaching to what happens in the lives of actual people. I'm also very impressed with the way you and your respondents are building a rich conversation of ideas!
ReplyDelete